Turtle Beach Resort
9049 Midnight Pass Road, Siesta Key, FL 34242
941.349.4554
www.turtlebeachresort.com
Ophelia’s On the Bay
9105 Midnight Pass Road, Sarasota, FL 34242
www.opheliasonthebay.net
After heading out from St. Armand’s Circle, we passed through Sarasota and on to Siesta Key. We were getting a bit desperate for someplace to stay for the night. Most of the places we had passed either didn’t fit what we wanted (ie, tall hotels with no charm) or only rented by the week. We finally found a place that seemed to fit our requirements - nightly rentals and lots of charm - but they had no availability. They pointed us down the road a bit further to a place called Turtle Beach Resort. I fell in love instantly when we pulled into the parking lot. It just looked like Old Florida and it was oozing charm. Stacey wasn’t so sure. She had really wanted something on the beach, and this was on the bay side of the island. No one was in the rental office, so we called the number posted on the door. They had availability for a 2-Bedroom cottage, very reasonable price, and it included a deal with Ophelia’s, the restaurant next door. For $40 per person you could get a 3-course meal there. This was also the restaurant that the waiter at Tommy Bahama’s had pointed us to. We decided to go with it, and the rental agent showed up about 15 minutes later to check us in. The cottage was really cute on the inside too. AND we had our own private hot tub on the patio out back, complete with a hammock and patio furniture. I kind of wished we were staying longer.
We called Ophelia’s and they were able to get us in for 7pm. It was too dark for any views of the bay by then, and it was still, in my opinion, too hot and clammy outside to want to sit out there. This IS August in Florida. It was also raining off and on. The inside of the restaurant needed a bit of updating. It reminded me of a remnant from the 1980’s, a lot of glass and mirrors. The waitress was a bit rough around the edges, and seemed a bit annoyed that we wanted to do the $40 special. And of course, the options are much more limited for that. I started out with a French Martini - not the best I’ve ever had, but still very good. I then opted for the Baby Arugula Salad with Blueberry Vinaigrette for my first course. The salad was fresh, but overall the taste was on the flat side. I was hoping for something a bit more zippy for the salad dressing. My main course was the Yellowtail Snapper with Apple Compote. I was hoping to repeat a similar meal experience I’d had in Key West last summer, but this fell hopelessly short. Maybe I was just still full from our incredibly late lunch, but it just didn’t make a huge impression on me. I followed up with the Creme Brulee for dessert. It was very good, but I think it’s hard to screw up that particular dessert. This is the place everyone thinks is the best restaurant on the island. I then wondered where we would eat if would have stayed longer. Overall, I would give Ophelia’s 1 1/2 stars out of 4.
Back at Turtle Beach Resort, we decided to take a dip in the hot tub. SQ had, unfortunately, turned the heat up so high we couldn’t stand to be in it. We turned the temp. down, then Stacey and I decided to go walking out on the resort-owned docks. This place was incredibly quiet, mostly small families and couples staying here. It would be a really, really romantic place to stay. Each cottage has it’s own hot tub, and there is a swimming pool. They also have lots of water equipment - kayaks, fishing poles, etc. There are covered swings all over the place too, several on the docks - VERY relaxing. Well, it wasn’t on the beach, but this was really nice. I’m still not sure if Stacey was crazy about the place, but SQ and I really enjoyed it. Back to reality tomorrow.